Search

MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Daryl Sartain is Director & Worldwide Head of #XR, Displays, and Wireless Ecosystems for @Radeon at @AMD. He is also Chair o…
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Arvind Kumar is a Senior Principal Engineer for @intel @IntelSoftware. At #IFCSummit he explained the workings of the Client…
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Neil Schneider’s #IFCSummit opening presentation. #CloudComputing https://t.co/CFqiNxSzPV
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Our #videogames in the #clienttocloud revolution is going on now featuring @playhatchglobal @AccelByteInc @awscloud and @Sha
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: On stage now, the #Crypto and #Blockchain markets with Professor Bebo White @bebo and Melissa Brown, Senior Director Develop…
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Finishing off our busy morning is Mark Morrison, Director of Sales for @magicleap. He was talking about Building ROI in the…
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Dominique Pouliquen CEO of @CintooCloud did a live demo of their #clienttocloud technology. #IFCSummit #CloudComputing #VR h…
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Next up is Stefan Holzer CTO of @fyusioninc on Democratizing #3D Content for #ecommerce. #IFCSummit #FutureComputing https:/…
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Enabling an Immersive World panel moderated by Kevin Krewel of @tiriasresearch with Alex Hornstein CTO of @LKGGlass Rama Kri…
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Vinay Narayan VP at @htcvive starts off the morning for us here at #IFCSummit. He is speaking on how #5G is powering the nex…
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: We finished the first day of #IFCSummit with a great Futurists Panel moderated by @deantak of @VentureBeat with @awscloud @D
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Some highlights of our busy morning here at #IFCSummit. With @IntelSoftware @AMDPC @AMDGaming @jonpeddie #futurecomputing #C
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: Hours left in our #Halloween  flash sale! Take over 600.00 off the price of a ticket today only! 👻🎃🧛🏼‍♂️🧟‍♀️#IFCSummit #Clou
MTBS3D RT @thekhronosgroup: Today only! Get access to the @IFCSummit for only $349. Happy Halloween! https://t.co/eg2jOce4eQ
MTBS3D RT @IFCSummit: #Halloween flash sale! Take over 600.00 off the price of a ticket today only! 👻🎃🧛🏼‍♂️🧟‍♀️#IFCSummit #CloudComputing #CloudGa
MTBS3D RT @TheFoundryTeam: Mathieu Mazerolle, our Cloud Product Manager will be speaking at The @IFCSummit running November 5-6, 2019 at the Compu…

When VR News is Dangerous

BBC News Logo
When MTBS got the headline "How virtual reality can bring news to life", we immediately thought this was going to be a creative use of a 3D 360 degree camera rig for VR news broadcasting. This is not the case. Instead, journalist and film-maker Nonny de la Pena has been using virtual reality recreations to help tell her news stories. As described in her BBC segment, she interviews people on the scene and recreates what happened in a virtual environment. In her opinion, VR becomes a great tool to give the viewers a stronger sense of presence, empathy and a deeper understanding of events.

Unfortunately, this is where things fall apart. It's a VR recreation; not actual camera footage. If people have emotional reactions to VR recreations, and the viewing public is led to believe that it's a 1:1 accurate account of what happened, how could anyone effectively differentiate news from deliberate propaganda? Imagine news and imagery being made from word of mouth alone - or worse, imagery and emotion that is orchestrated from imagination rather than being pasted together by source material that has to be scrutinized? What if so called VR news isn't sourced from journalists at all?

An article, radio piece, or traditional broadcast leaves much to the imagination - and that's actually a good thing. We need those gaps because it leaves room to fill things in with other parts of the story from multiple sources. There is room for debate, discussion and personal decision making. However, if we begin to accept VR recreations as factual accounts of what happened, and if we have evidence that these recreations are going to have an involuntary emotional response, then the whole concept of journalistic integrity and what it means to hold up to scrutiny are going to get thrown out the window.

Now if this was a documentary movie or Ron Howard film, then that would be fine. Everyone going in to the theater knows they are there to be emotionally attached to the story and perspective - but that's Hollywood! The audience knows that after they leave the theater, and they look up Apollo 13 on Wikipedia, they are going to find a hundred inaccuracies compared to real life. They accept it because they went to see that film to be entertained. The responsibilities are very different in the case of VR news broadcast recreations, and there is an added risk that experiences will be engineered to maximize emotional response rather than level headed news reporting.

While the positive intentions are there and it's important to experiment with new forms of media, if VR recreations were to get traction, this could mark a very dangerous path for broadcast news and public scrutiny.  This is of course just our opinion...what's yours?