image crosseyed or parralel? #2

[yuriythebest]

please help MTBS by saying if you think this image is in crosseyed or parallel. My position is that it's in parallel.

what do you think?

[WheatstoneHolmes]

Keeps saying "The submitted form was invalid."

It is parallel.

[Likay]

Poll not worky but the image is 100% parallell without doubts!

[Neil]

Ok. Here is the full sized image:

http://mtbs3d.com/gallery/albums/userpi ... dFINAL.JPG" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Look carefully at the screws on the left hand side of the door (one screw on top of the other screw).

Remember that the door is flushed outward, away from the camera.

On the right image, the screws are closer to the left edge than the screws in the left image. Remember that for depth, the left image coincides with the left eye, and the right image coincides with the right. It only reverses for out of screen effects.

http://www.mtbs3d.com/index.php?option= ... mitstart=1" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Look at the cans. In the right image, the cans are closer to the left, and in the left image, the cans are closer to the right. Same thing!

I'm guessing it's the nature of the picture that is giving this illusion that it is in parallel, when it really isn't.

Regards,
Neil

[Neil]

You know what? I cropped this picture in stereo photo maker, and it did it's own alignment process. I wonder if it got all the depth cues mixed up in the process.

Regards,
Neil

[Likay]

The image IS in parallell format: Here's the downloaded, reversed image: http://www.mtbs3d.com/gallery/displayim ... ?pos=-3720" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

There are no questions: The best visual example is by looking at the cans/stuffs on the lower levels which appears being in front of the cat instead. The paint in those shelves looks like some kind of frost on a glassdoor.

Edit : Posted while post in between. And yes: spm can sometimes be confusing working with since it's so easy to shift views and forget how it was aligned. However it's really easy to see this if you can look crosseyed. It's also very easy to shift views in a stereoviewer since almost none of them (sview do though) says if images are shifted.

[Neil]

I looked at the original MPO file prior to stereo photomaker adjustments. I was correct, the image got distorted (and it is crosseyed!).

Will fix.

Regards,
Neil

[yuriythebest]

um, still parallel

[cybereality]

Well, the polls broken (and has been broken for months) but thats besides the point.

Anyway, I don't know what you guys are smoking but the image is cross-eyed for sure. Look right above the cat food in the middle. You should see a little bit of a green ginger-ale bottle. On the right side of the image you are seeing more of the bottle behind the cabinet door, indicating that view is the left side. Meaning it is a cross-eye image, no doubt.

[Neil]

The voting works. It was fixed before and stopped without warning. Fixed it again. I just had to clean the cache. Bizarre!

Just PM a heads up next time there is a problem.

Regards,
Neil

[Likay]

Well, the polls broken (and has been broken for months) but thats besides the point.

Anyway, I don't know what you guys are smoking but the image is cross-eyed for sure. Look right above the cat food in the middle. You should see a little bit of a green ginger-ale bottle. On the right side of the image you are seeing more of the bottle behind the cabinet door, indicating that view is the left side. Meaning it is a cross-eye image, no doubt.

Too late out. The original image is changed and is indeed in crossview format now.

[Okta]

Cross eyed.

[yuriythebest]

yup now it's in crosseyed

[Neil]

I created the new image the way I did the old. Except I turned off stereo photomaker's auto alignment features. I'm almost certain it created an unnatural distortion.

Poor Tuo-Te! So much focus on whether or not the image is cross-eyed, and not enough recognition for his grade 5 reading abilities!

Regards,
Neil

[Likay]

The cats surely know the labels on their cans, be sure of that. They also know exactly when you're going to feed them (if you don't they let you know... ). Like with dogs they have a sense for time (sometimes within minutes...) and knows when you arrive from work (even if they can't hear the car) etc etc....